Skip to Main Content

NUR 4700 (Research Proposal Development)

Resources for NUR 4700 students.

Evidence Based Practice (EBP)

Evidence-Based Practice (EBP) is a problem-solving approach to clinical decision-making within health care. It integrates the best available scientific evidence with the best available experiential patient and practitioner evidence. EBP considers internal and external influences on practice and encourages critical thinking.

EBP helps healthcare professionals make efficient use of resources by focusing on interventions that have been proven effective. This can lead to better resource allocation, reduced unnecessary procedures, and cost-effective healthcare delivery.

Employing evidence-based practices enhances the professional credibility of healthcare providers. It demonstrates a commitment to staying current with the latest research and applying that knowledge to patient care. This is particularly important in an ever-evolving field like medicine.

On this page you will find resources to help you apply EBP principles to your research. Find resources including systematic reviews, critically appraised topics and articles, and practice guidelines.

Steps for Acquiring Evidence 

  1. Identify a clinical problem and create a well-defined research question (using the PICO framework)
  2. Translate the PICO framework into a search strategy

    • Brainstorm and gather synonyms

    • Construct the search strategy

  3. Select the best available resources (databases)
  4. Tailor search strategy to database(s)
  5. Assess results and appraise studies 
  6. Save search & export results to a reference manager (Zotero or Research Matrix)

PICO Framework

First you need to define a problem and formulate a clinical question. In the research process, this is the research question or statement. In the clinical setting, ‘asking a question’ may become part of a research study, a quality improvement project, or lead to evidence-based practice.

A commonly used format for creating a clinical question is known as PICO or PICO(T), which refers to: Patient/Problem, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome and occasionally Timeframe/Type of Study.

 

 

Clinical Question

Most common type of clinical questions: Therapy, Diagnosis, Harm, Prognosis

Therapy  determining the effect of interventions on patient-important outcomes
Diagnosis establishing the power of a test to differentiate between those with and without a target condition or disease
Etiology/Harm
ascertaining the effects of potentially harmful agents on patient-important outcomes
Prognosis
estimating a patient's future course

 

Examples of Clinical Questions Using PICO Framework

You have a patient who has difficulty type 2 diabetes and wan to know if regular exercise and life style modification would lead to better glycemic control compared to medication alone 

P = patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus

I = regular exercise & modified lifestyle 

C = standard medical management alone

O = glycemic control 

Clinical Question: In patients with COPD, does using pursed lip breathing, as compared to regular breathing, improve exercise endurance?

 

You are working with a recent stroke patient who is having balance issues and you are considering using virtual reality in their therapy.

P = recent stroke, balance issues

I = virtual reality

C = no virtual reality

O = improved balance

Clinical Question: In recent stroke patients, how does using virtual reality affect or improve balance?

Searching with PICO Framework

  •  Develop keywords for each of the applicable PICO elements of your topic.
  •  Start your search by combining 2 or 3 PICO elements with Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT)
  •  Look for subject headings that represent your keyword and PICO  elements.
  •  Apply limiters depending on your topic, and consider what is the best type of study for your question.

Construct PICO Search Strategies 

Search strings are constructed searches that combine concepts with Boolean operators (AND, OR, NOT). You can start building a search string by using keywords from your list of PICO terms and synonyms or related terms of them and then move to established subject terms that databases use to tag item records. 

 

Selecting Databases

The following databases are ideal for finding evidence-based literature:

Appraise Evidence

Depending on your research question, you need to address what type of study would provide the best evidence. When searching for articles, databases often have filters allowing you to acquire specific types of studies. 

 

Below is a list of the different types of studies often seen in those filters. 

Systematic Review: It is an intensive review of the literature on a given topic. It uses explicit and rigorous methods to identify the studies included in the review. It also critically appraises and synthesizes all the studies included in the review. - secondary research 

Meta-Analysis: Similarly to a systematic they overview extensively the literature on a topic, but they combine the results of all the studies identified in a quantitative way. They synthesizing summaries and make a conclusion that may be used to evaluate therapeutic effectiveness. - secondary research

Randomized Controlled Trial: It is a clinical trial that involves at least one test treatment and one control treatment. There was concurrent enrollment and follows up of the test- and control-treated groups, and in which the treatments were administered by a random process.- primary research

Cohort Study: A study in which subsets of a defined population are identified and studies over a period of time to see the effects of something. - primary research 

Case Control Study: A study that starts with the identification of persons with a disease of interest and a control group without the disease. The relationship of an attribute to the disease is examined by comparing diseased and non-diseased persons with regard to the frequency or levels of the attribute in each group. - primary research

Case Series / Reports: Articles written about one patient or a series of patients with the same issue. Great for rare diseases, disorders, and drug/treatment reactions. Not the best source of evidence because it focuses on a small group of people, but sometimes it's the only source.

Qualitive VS Quantitative

Qualitative Research

Uses words to describe human behaviors. It answers a wide variety of questions related to human responses to actual or potential health problems. The purpose of qualitative research is to describe, explore and explain the health-related phenomena being studied.

Quantitative Research

Uses numbers to obtain precise measurements that can later be statistically analyzed.  Many quantitative studies test hypotheses.  It follows a systematic, subjective approach to examine the relationship between variables with the primary goal being to analyze and represent that relationship mathematically through statistical analysis.  This is the type of research approach most commonly used in scientific research problems.